Date: Tuesday, 14-Jan-97 22:51:46 GMT
Server: NCSA/1.3
MIME-version: 1.0
Content-type: text/html

<HTML><HEAD>
<!-- This document was created from RTF source by rtftohtml version 3.0.1 -->
<TITLE>Without a title - Title</TITLE></HEAD>
<BODY BACKGROUND="../images/r2harch.gif" TEXT=#1809BB>
<hr size=4>
<H1>
<b>CS 577a, Fall 1996 </b><p>
<b>WinWin Negotiation Grading Criteria</b><p>
</h1>
<hr size=4>
<b></b><p>
<b><center></b>The maximum number of points were 100. At most 10 bonus points
were possible:<p>
<p>
</center>
<TABLE BORDER>
<TR rowspan=1 align="left">
<TD colspan=1 align="left">Criterion
<BR></TD>
<TD colspan=1 align="left">Points
<BR></TD></TR><TR rowspan=1 align="left">
<TD colspan=1 align="left">Thorough
application of WinWin artifacts<p>
*       good bodies, attributes<p>
*       Thorough cross-references
<BR></TD>
<TD colspan=1 align="left">-20
<BR></TD></TR><TR rowspan=1 align="left">
<TD colspan=1 align="left">Effective
negotiation process<p>
*       Good ID of Issues, Options<p>
*       Good comments<p>
*       Effective agreement process<p>
*       Negotiation schedule
<BR></TD>
<TD colspan=1 align="left">-20
<BR></TD></TR><TR rowspan=1 align="left">
<TD colspan=1 align="left">Consistent
Cost/Schedule (or COCOMO) result
<BR></TD>
<TD colspan=1 align="left">-15
<BR></TD></TR><TR rowspan=1 align="left">
<TD colspan=1 align="left">Thorough
application of terminology (Terms)
<BR></TD>
<TD colspan=1 align="left">-5
<BR></TD></TR><TR rowspan=1 align="left">
<TD colspan=1 align="left">Detailed
and complete Taxonomy
<BR></TD>
<TD colspan=1 align="left">-5
<BR></TD></TR><TR rowspan=1 align="left">
<TD colspan=1 align="left">Participation
of stakeholders
<BR></TD>
<TD colspan=1 align="left">-5
<BR></TD></TR><TR rowspan=1 align="left">
<TD colspan=1 align="left">Completeness
of Negotiation<p>
*       Compared to taxonomy<p>
*       Unresolved Issues, uncovered Win Conditions<p>
*       others
<BR></TD>
<TD colspan=1 align="left">-25
<BR></TD></TR><TR rowspan=1 align="left">
<TD colspan=1 align="left">Summary
<BR></TD>
<TD colspan=1 align="left">-5
<BR></TD></TR><TR rowspan=1 align="left">
<TD colspan=1 align="left">Good
suggestions on WinWin improvement and bug report
<BR></TD>
<TD colspan=1 align="left">+5
<BR></TD></TR><TR rowspan=1 align="left">
<TD colspan=1 align="left">Especially
creative solution
<BR></TD>
<TD colspan=1 align="left">+5
<BR></TD></TR></TABLE><p>
<P><hr size=4>
</body></html>
